You will usually review the pilot episode of a show and perhaps one subsequent episode. It is possible to review shows at other times, such as at the end of a season, but most reviews are sought at the beginning of a show or season.
Research new shows. Many entertainment magazine and websites have previews for an upcoming television season. This is an easy way to learn what is coming and what might appeal to you.
Research the cast. Most new shows have at least one well-known actor who serves as a draw for the whole concept. Learn what other things that lead actor has done, and decide whether those accomplishments have prepared him for a show such as this one. Find out what lesser-known cast members have done as well.
Research the behind-the-scene creators. Among the most important of these are the writers; writing is as important as acting in the success or failure of a program. What other shows have these writers done, either individually or as part of a team? What about the producers? What does the studio have to say about this new project?
When the time comes, watch the pilot episode. If possible, record it so you can review important scenes.
Take notes. If you record the show, it's a good idea is to simply sit and watch it the first time around, then take notes the second time through. Jot down the scenes that made you laugh, the relationships that were interesting to you, the parts of the show that you thought were boring or stupid.
How did you feel about this program? At the end of the first episode, did you want to know more about these characters in this setting, or were you disappointed? Did you think the star let you down, or did she deliver another excellent character? Are you looking forward to watching another episode to see what happens, or were you glad to finally turn off the TV?
The first step is an introduction. This short part should give the name and network of the show, the major stars and any information about the writers and producers that is relevant. It should also mention the time and day it airs.
Give a summary of both the concept (workers in an office are being filmed as part of a documentary, and we follow them through their day) and the episode (Regional Manager Michael Scott lets rumors of downsizing leak to his employees, then has to try to calm their panic).
Identify the positive aspects of the show. Give at least one specific example from the show that illustrates the show's strengths. Even if you had an overall negative impression of the show, point out any positives from the show.
Identify the negative aspects of the show. Give at least one specific example that illustrates something the show could improve on in future episodes. Even if you had an overall positive impression of the show, the show likely has areas where it can grow.
Conclude by offering your recommendation as to whether people should invest their time and emotional commitment in this show. Should they skip this one or give it a chance? You might approach this by simply stating what you intend to do yourself and why.
Post or publish your review on a website or blog.