Doris Day's Least Favorite Film: "Love Me or Leave Me" (1955)
Doris Day identified Love Me or Leave Me (1955) as the film she disliked most in her entire career.
Why She Regretted It
- Against Type: She played Ruth Etting—a tough, hard-edged, alcoholic torch singer. Day felt this betrayed her established wholesome persona and alienated her core audience.
- Director Conflict: She clashed with Charles Walters over characterization and tone.
- Studio Pressure: Day believed MGM deliberately cast her against type to "stretch" her—a move she resented as manipulative.
Outcome
Despite a Golden Globe nomination and solid box office, Day considered the film a career misstep. She later said, "I didn't want to play a woman who was that hard. It wasn't me."
The irony: critics often cite it as her best dramatic performance. But for Day, authenticity > acclaim.