Can You Turn a Normal Pidgeot Shiny in FireRed or Diamond? No—Shininess Is Set at Encounter
No. Shininess is determined at the moment of encounter/generation. There is no in-game method to change a caught Pokémon's shininess in any generation.
Legitimate Shiny Hunting (Gen III/IV)
- Masuda Method: Breed parents from different-language games (1/1366 in Gen IV, 1/683 Gen V+).
- Chain Fishing / Poké Radar Chaining: Increases odds incrementally.
- Shiny Charm (Gen V+): Completing National Dex triples base odds.
- Soft Resetting: For stationary legendaries/gift Pokémon.
In FireRed/Diamond, your only legit path is re-encountering a shiny Pidgey/Pidgeotto via the above methods—not converting an existing one.