Did Harry Potter Cast a Spell in Front of a Muggle in Order of the Phoenix?
No. The Order of the Phoenix's operations (Headquarters at 12 Grimmauld Place, Ministry battles, Department of Mysteries) involved only witches and wizards—including Muggle-borns like Hermione, but no non-magical Muggles.
You might be misremembering:
- Harry using magic on Dudley (Dementor attack, Order of the Phoenix Ch. 1) — but Dudley isn't a Muggle bystander; he's family, and it's self-defense.
- The Half-Blood Prince cave scene (Muggle orphanage flashback) — young Tom Riddle, not Harry.
- A film-only moment? (The movies add/subtract scenes.)
Share the specific scene you recall—spell, location, witnesses—and I'll pinpoint the source.