How to Ask a Shakespeare Question on an Academic Listserv: A Guide to Productive Inquiry
Scholarly listservs (SHAKSPER, Shakespeare Forum, SSA Discussion List) are invaluable resources—if you approach them with professionalism and preparation. Here's how to get the best help.
- Choose the Right List: Match your question's level (graduate, pedagogical, textual, performance) to the list's focus.
- Craft an Informative Subject Line:
Query: Falstaff's "honor" catechism (1HIV 5.1) is better than Question about Falstaff.
- Write a Concise, Structured Message:
- State your question clearly in the first paragraph.
- Provide context: What edition are you using? What's your argument or confusion?
- Quote the specific lines (act.scene.line) you're wrestling with.
- Show Your Homework: Mention editions, commentaries, or articles you've already consulted. "I've checked Arden3, Wells/Oxford, and Greenblatt's intro, but..." signals seriousness.
- Be Polite and Respectful: Academics volunteer time. "I would be grateful for any insights" goes further than "Explain this to me."
- Follow List Rules: Some forbid attachments; some require plain text; some moderate first posts. Read the FAQ.
- Thank Respondents: Acknowledge replies, even if you disagree. Summarize what you learned for the archives.
Golden Rule
Treat the list as a scholarly community, not a search engine. Collaboration and respect yield the richest answers.