On Broadway, a turkey is a show that flops critically and commercially—likely to close quickly. The term supposedly originates from early theatergoers throwing rotten tomatoes at bad performances: since a turkey could supply enough rotten tomatoes for a crowd, it became a metaphor for a disastrous production.
"That show was a total turkey—closed in three weeks." It's industry shorthand, used by producers, critics, and theater-goers alike. The bird's association with Thanksgiving (sacrifice, consumption) adds a dark undertone: the show gets eaten alive.