Does Ismene Join Antigone? No — Her Refusal Defines the Play's Central Conflict
Ismene's Choice in Sophocles' Antigone
In the prologue, Antigone asks Ismene to help bury their brother Polyneices, defying Creon's edict. Ismene refuses, saying:
"We are women, not born to contend with men... I shall obey those in authority." (Lines 62, 67)
Why She Refuses
- Fear of death: The penalty is public stoning.
- Gendered socialization: She internalizes Athenian norms: women's domain is oikos (household), not polis (public law).
- Pragmatism: She sees the act as futile — one gesture won't change the law.
- Sisterly protection: She later tries to share blame, offering to die with Antigone — revealing love beneath compliance.
Dramatic Function
Ismene's refusal isolates Antigone, making her defiance solitary and absolute. It establishes the play's dialectic:
- Antigone: Divine law, family, conscience, action
- Ismene: Human law, survival, compromise, inaction
- Creon: State law, order, authority, rigidity
Ismene isn't "weak" — she represents the ordinary human calculation Antigone transcends. Her later attempt to die with her sister ("I am not ashamed to share your danger") complicates her initial choice, suggesting dormant courage awakened by love.