Protagonist Status in Greek vs. Elizabethan Tragedy: A Critical Distinction
The statement "The protagonist is an ordinary person" is false as a commonality between Greek and Elizabethan tragedy. In both traditions, the tragic protagonist is characteristically high-born, elevated, or exceptional—a king, prince, general, or noble whose fall carries communal consequences.
Greek Tragedy: The Aristocratic Requirement
- Aristotle's Poetics (Ch. 13): Tragedy imitates actions of "serious, complete, and of a certain magnitude" by persons "of high reputation and prosperity"
- Canonical Examples: Oedipus (King), Agamemnon (King), Medea (Princess/Priestess), Antigone (Princess), Ajax (Great Warrior)
- Function: High status amplifies the fall; the polity suffers with the individual
Elizabethan Tragedy: The Noble Protagonist
- Shakespeare's Tragedies: Hamlet (Prince), Lear (King), Macbeth (Thane/King), Othello (General), Coriolanus (General), Antony (Triumvir), Timon (Wealthy Noble)
- Contemporaries: Marlowe's Tamburlaine (Conqueror), Faustus (Scholar-Exceptional); Webster's Duchess (Duchess), Flamineo (Noble); Middleton's Revenger (Noble)
- Domestic Tragedy Exception: Arden of Faversham, A Yorkshire Tragedy feature non-noble protagonists—but these are explicit subgenre innovations, not the norm
Why the Distinction Matters
The "ordinary person" protagonist emerges with modern tragedy (Ibsen, Miller, Williams)—where the common man's suffering claims tragic dignity. Arthur Miller's essay "Tragedy and the Common Man" (1949) explicitly argues for this shift. Attributing it to Greek or Elizabethan tradition anachronistically projects modern democratic sensibilities onto hierarchical dramatic forms.