Arts >> Theater >> Drama

Richard III: Separating Historical Crimes from Shakespearean Villainy

The historical Richard III (1452–1485) has been accused of numerous crimes, but many attributions stem from Tudor propaganda—particularly Shakespeare's dramatization. Here's a critical examination of the major allegations.

Princes in the Tower (1483)

Edward V (12) and Richard, Duke of York (9) disappeared after Richard became Lord Protector then king. Contemporary rumors accused Richard; modern historians debate his guilt. No conclusive evidence exists. The 1674 discovery of child skeletons in the Tower remains inconclusive.

Henry VI's Death (1471)

Henry VI died in the Tower after Edward IV's restoration. Official cause: "melancholy." Richard (then Duke of Gloucester) was present. Thomas More's later account claims Richard killed him—plausible but unproven.

Earl of Warwick (1471)

Richard Neville, "the Kingmaker," died at the Battle of Barnet fighting against Edward IV. Richard fought on Edward's side. No evidence Richard personally killed him or ordered mutilation.

Edward of Westminster (1471)

Lancastrian Prince of Wales died at Tewkesbury. Contemporary accounts say he was killed fleeing battle; later Tudor sources claim Richard murdered him personally.

George, Duke of Clarence (1478)

Executed for treason by Edward IV (not Richard) after parliamentary attainder. The "drowned in malmsey" story appears in Shakespeare but lacks contemporary confirmation.

Lollard Persecution

Richard's brief reign (1483–1485) saw no notable heresy prosecutions. Lollard suppression peaked under Henry IV and Henry V.

Yorkist Dynasty's End

Richard was the last Yorkist king. His death at Bosworth (1485) ended the Wars of the Roses, beginning Tudor rule under Henry VII.

Historical Assessment

Richard was a ruthless medieval nobleman in a violent era, but the "monster" portrait largely derives from Tudor historians (More, Vergil) and Shakespeare—serving Henry VII's legitimization needs. The historical Richard is more complex, and far less cartoonish, than Shakespeare's villain.

Drama

Related Categories