Current editorial standards (Chicago Manual of Style, MLA, AP) agree: titles of full-length, standalone musical stage productions are italicized, not placed in quotation marks.
| Format | Examples |
|---|---|
| Italicize (Long-form, standalone theatrical works) | La Traviata, The Magic Flute, Hamilton, Wicked, The Phantom of the Opera, Porgy and Bess |
| Quotation Marks (Songs, arias, short numbers *from* those works) | "Nessun dorma", "Defying Gravity", "My Shot", "Tonight", "Summertime" |
It mirrors the book/chapter or album/track hierarchy. The *production* is the major work (like a book or album); the *song* is a component (like a chapter or track). This applies to operas, operettas, musicals, ballets, revues, and oratorios.
Bottom line: If it has a libretto, a plot, and an intermission, italicize it.