John Hopley Neligan's Reaction in "The Adventure of the Dancing Men"
Correction: John Hopley Neligan appears in "The Adventure of the Dancing Men" (not "Black Peter"). He's a suspect in the Hilton Cubitt murder.
His Reaction When Confronted by Holmes
- Shock & Denial: Visibly shaken, protests innocence.
- Confession of a Secret: Admits he was the "dancing men" correspondent—trying to recover money stolen from his father by a criminal gang.
- Exoneration: Holmes proves he didn't commit the murder; Neligan is cleared, leaving relief and gratitude.
His arc: suspicious outsider → wrongly accused → vindicated truth-teller.