There is no historical record of a “slight shudder” on the evening of April 12, 1912 aboard the Titanic. The ship was still in the North Atlantic, two days from the collision.
The iceberg impact occurred at 11:40 PM, April 14. Survivors described a jarring, grinding vibration—the sound of the berg scraping the starboard side—not a sudden “shudder.” The distinction matters: the damage was a long, narrow opening across multiple watertight compartments, not a single puncture.
Rely on documented accounts (British/US inquiries, survivor testimonies). Verify any claim against the established timeline to avoid misinformation.