No diary entry reads "Today, Will's first play premiered." But scholarship converges on Henry VI, Part 1 as the earliest surviving play, debuting c. 1590–1592.
Early performances were by the Lord Chamberlain's Men (Shakespeare's company) at The Theatre in Shoreditch (their home until 1598) or possibly the Rose (Henslowe's venue, where the diary entries appear). The companies shared actors and venues fluidly.
The exact night is lost. But the play that launched the greatest theatrical career in English? It was a history play about a boy king, a warrior saint, and a nation at war—fitting, for a playwright about to conquer his own realm.