Broadway as an institution—distinct from "theatre in New York"—has a birthday: 1895. That's when the Herald Square Theatre opened at 35th Street and Broadway, the first purpose-built venue in what would become the concentrated "Great White Way" district.
These venues created critical mass. Producers, agents, actors, audiences—they all clustered. By 1920, the Times Square–42nd Street corridor had dozens of theatres. The "Broadway" brand was born: professional, commercial, 500+ seats, concentrated in Manhattan's Theater District and Lincoln Center area.
41 professional theatres currently constitute Broadway. The Herald Square Theatre was demolished in 1915, but its ghost is in every marquee. The district moved, the theatres changed, but 1895 remains the Year Zero.