Speak to a travel agent who typically has access to Broadway show packages. He can book accommodations, show tickets and dinner into your trip. Work with one of the agents at Liberty Travel to see which Broadway show packages and deals they can offer you.
Find online Broadway show package sites. Multiple sites offer different types of Broadway show packages. You'll find some of the best values on the NYC Theater Packages and Broadway.com.
Choose your accommodations from the provided list on the online booking site, and pick a hotel near the Theater District. Try the Belvedere Hotel and the Millennium Broadway Hotel.