Jolson Voice Replacement Myth in The Jolson Story: Debunked
Myth: Studio replaced Al Jolson’s vocals with an impersonator (Walter Craig/Grant).
Reality:
- Jolson sang all musical numbers (lip-synced by Larry Parks).
- Parks spoke dialogue; Jolson’s voice is the soundtrack.
- Columbia was delighted—film was a blockbuster.
- No impersonator was hired; the “difference” listeners perceive is Jolson’s own stylistic range.
The rumor likely stems from Parks’ limited on-screen singing and Jolson’s varying vocal tone across recordings.