Arts >> Movies & TV >> Reality TV

Is "The Amityville Horror" a True Story?

It is presented as based on true events, but widely disputed.

The Claims

The Lutz family (George, Kathy, children) moved into 112 Ocean Avenue, Amityville, NY in Dec 1975—13 months after Ronald DeFeo Jr. murdered his family there. They fled after 28 days, claiming: poltergeist activity, slime, flies, cold spots, levitation, demonic voices, cloven hoofprints, a hidden "red room," and George waking at 3:15 AM (DeFeo's murder time). Jay Anson's 1977 book The Amityville Horror and the 1979 film popularized it.

Evidence For

Evidence Against

Verdict: Most skeptics and investigators consider it a hoax or gross exaggeration. The house (renumbered, renovated) remains a private residence. The franchise (20+ films) is fiction inspired by a real murder.

Reality TV

Related Categories