Should Children Read Shakespeare? Pros and Cons
The debate over children reading Shakespeare involves developmental, educational, and cultural considerations.
Arguments For
- Literary foundation: Core cultural literacy; references permeate English language/media.
- Language development: Expands vocabulary, syntactic complexity, metaphorical thinking.
- Emotional intelligence: Complex characters model empathy, perspective-taking.
- Critical thinking: Ambiguity, subtext, multiple interpretations demand analysis.
- Performance skills: Speaking verse builds confidence, diction, presence.
- Historical gateway: Entry point to Renaissance, Elizabethan England, theater history.
- Shared cultural touchstone: Intergenerational conversation; global canon.
Arguments Against / Cautions
- Language barrier: Early Modern English ≠ Modern English; frustration risk.
- Mature content: Violence (Titus, Macbeth), sexuality (Romeo & Juliet, Othello), racism (Merchant, Othello), antisemitism, misogyny.
- Cultural distance: Gender/class/race assumptions require framing.
- Time investment: Full plays demand sustained attention; competing media.
- Pedagogical risk: Taught poorly → lifelong aversion ("Shakespeare trauma").
Recommended Approach
- Age-appropriate entry: 8–10: abridged prose (Lambs' Tales, Nesbit); 11–13: graphic novels, film; 14+: original text with support.
- Performance-first: See/act scenes before reading.
- Curated selection: Comedy (Midsummer, Twelfth Night) before tragedy.
- Modern translations alongside: No Fear Shakespeare, RSC editions.
- Contextualize: Discuss problematic elements explicitly.
- Connect: Link themes to contemporary life (jealousy, ambition, identity).
Verdict: Yes, with scaffolding. The benefits outweigh risks if introduced thoughtfully.