What Does More's Utopia Blame for Society's Problems? Greed, Inequality, Pride
More's Utopia doesn't blame a single cause. Through Raphael Hythloday, it diagnoses interlocking systemic failures in 16th-century Europe:
Primary Drivers
- Greed/Avarice: Enclosure movement — lords evict peasants for sheep pasture (wool profit)
- Private Property: Creates zero-sum competition; "where every man seeks his own, the common good perishes"
- Pride/Status: Luxury consumption, fashion, hierarchy — wasteful and corrupting
- Bad Laws: Protect property not people; punish poverty (theft from hunger)
- War-Mongering: Princes fight for glory; people pay in blood/taxes
- Religious Hypocrisy: Clergy accumulate wealth; laity persecuted for conscience
- Misused Talent: Smart men become lawyers/merchants not philosophers/statesmen
The Utopian Antidote
Communal property + limited labor + rational governance + religious tolerance = conditions where these pathologies cannot root.
More's Nuance
Book 1 (dialogue) presents these critiques through Hythloday. More-the-character pushes back: "Utopia works for Utopians; England needs gradual reform." The text stages the debate rather than resolving it. More was executed by Henry VIII in 1535—living the danger of radical critique.