- Isaac Powell as Tony
- Shereen Pimentel as Maria
- David Alvarez as Bernardo
- Ariana DeBose as Anita
- Amar Ramasar as Riff
- Skye Dakota Turner as Anybodys
- Ricardo Zayas as Chino
- Yesenia Ayala as Rosalia
- Daniel Patrick Russell as Officer Krupke
- Marc Kudisch as Doc
- Lee Sellars as Glad Hand
The production also featured an ensemble of 30 actors and dancers.