No film titled "The Wager" from 1912 appears in major archives (FIAF, BFI, IMDb, silent film databases). However, similarly titled shorts bracket that year:
1912 was a transitional year: the industry was shifting from one-reelers to feature-length films. Notable 1912 releases include From the Manger to the Cross, D.W. Griffith's The Musketeers of Pig Alley, and Helen Gardner's Cleopatra.
If you have a plot or actor in mind, it’s likely the 1911 Vitagraph short misdated in a source.