Gerard Butler's Singing in The Phantom of the Opera (2004): Dubbed by Colm Wilkinson
Gerard Butler did not sing his own vocals. The Phantom’s singing voice was performed by Colm Wilkinson, the original West End/Broadway Phantom (1986–1989).
- Butler: Spoke the dialogue; lip-synced to Wilkinson’s recordings.
- Wilkinson: Recorded all singing tracks (“The Music of the Night,” “The Point of No Return,” etc.).
- Emmy Rossum (Christine) and Patrick Wilson (Raoul) did sing their own parts.
Director Joel Schumacher chose Wilkinson for vocal authenticity; Butler focused on physical performance.