The name Three Skeleton Key does not come from literal skeleton keys. It derives from the last names of three lighthouse keepers who served there:
The island was named after these three men. The famous short story "Three Skeleton Key" by Georges-Gustave Toudouze (1937) popularized the name worldwide. The tale—about a lighthouse besieged by a horde of sea rats—is a classic of survival horror, but the title's origin is surprisingly mundane: a roll call of keepers.