No. In Pokémon Emerald (Gen 3):
Great Balls are strictly better for catching.
In Generation 4 onward, Premier Balls have a higher shiny catch rate due to a separate shiny-check formula (they use a different random number call). This does not apply in Emerald (Gen 3). In Emerald, shiny odds are fixed (1/8192) and ball type does not affect them.
Summary: Use Great Balls (or Ultra Balls / Timer Balls / Net Balls) for general catching in Emerald. Premier Balls are just a cosmetic bonus (white/red design) for buying 10+ Poké Balls.