* Colm Wilkinson: The original Phantom, he set the standard for the role with his powerful vocals and haunting portrayal. He's often considered the definitive Phantom by many fans.
* Gerard Butler: Known for his strong stage presence and charisma, Butler brought a more rugged and physically imposing Phantom to the screen in the 2004 film adaptation.
* Howard McGillin: He played the Phantom for a record-breaking 1,884 performances on Broadway, known for his nuanced acting and emotional depth.
* Anthony Crivello: He starred in the 1989 film adaptation, known for his intense and dramatic portrayal.
* Michael Crawford: Another iconic Phantom, he won a Tony Award for his performance in the original London production, known for his operatic voice and theatrical flair.
Ultimately, the best Phantom for you will depend on your own personal taste. Some might prefer the raw power of Colm Wilkinson, while others might be drawn to the more nuanced performance of Howard McGillin. There's no right or wrong answer!
Here are some additional points to consider:
* The production: The quality of the entire production, including direction, set design, and the other performers, can influence how you perceive the Phantom.
* Personal preference: Your own taste in acting, singing, and stage presence will impact who you consider the best Phantom.
Rather than trying to find the "best," it's more enriching to appreciate the unique talents of each actor and their individual interpretations of this iconic role.