You are thinking of Aqua Teen Hunger Force (Adult Swim, 2000–2015).
The character is Master Shake — a milkshake (cup, straw, lid) with a single green alien arm extending from his side (sometimes depicted as a tentacle or robotic limb). He has no legs (moves by hopping/sliding) and no other arms.
Other Adult Swim characters with odd limbs: Carl Brutananadilewski (human, normal arms), Early Cuyler (Squidbillies, squid arms), Harvey Birdman (normal). Master Shake is the iconic "guy with an alien arm."