Arts >> Theater >> Musicals

Shakespeare's "The Fault Is Not in Our Stars": Cassius to Brutus in Julius Caesar

The famous lines—

"The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars,
But in ourselves, that we are underlings."

—come from Julius Caesar, Act 1, Scene 2, spoken by Cassius to Brutus.

Context

Cassius is recruiting Brutus for the conspiracy against Caesar. Brutus hesitates, citing fate or the gods. Cassius reframes: their subservience is not written in the heavens ("our stars") but in their own passivity. He urges Brutus to claim agency—to act rather than suffer.

Why It Resonates

The line has become a secular credo for self-determination. It rejects astrological determinism in favor of human responsibility. John Green borrowed it for his novel title The Fault in Our Stars, inverting the meaning: sometimes the fault is in our stars (cancer, biology), and courage lies in living anyway.

Musicals

Related Categories