Girls Aloud were formed on "Popstars: The Rivals" (2002) but did not win the final public vote. The format pitted a boy band against a girl group. The boy band One True Voice won the Christmas #1 single race with "Sacred Trust / After You're Gone" vs. Girls Aloud's "Sound of the Underground."
But here's the twist: Girls Aloud's single hit #1; One True Voice's peaked at #9. The public voted for the boys, but bought the girls' record. One True Voice disbanded in 2003. Girls Aloud launched a 10-year, 21-top-10 career.
Lost the show. Won the war.