Contrasting Concepts of Love in Romeo and Juliet Act 1, Scene 1: Petrarchan vs. Bawdy
Act 1, Scene 1 (not the Capulet ball—Scene 5) presents two male‑centric, pre‑Juliet views of love:
1. Petrarchan / Courtly Love (Romeo on Rosaline)
- Idealized, unrequited, rhetorical.
- Romeo speaks in oxymorons: "O brawling love! O loving hate!"
- Performance of suffering; self‑absorbed.
2. Physical / Bawdy Love (Sampson, Gregory, Mercutio)
- Sexual conquest, aggression, humor.
- Sampson: "I will push Montague's men from the wall, and thrust his maids to the wall."
- Mercutio's Queen Mab speech (Scene 4) reduces love to lust and dreams.
Contrast: Romeo's later love for Juliet (Scene 5) transcends both—mutual, spiritual, yet embodied.