Romeo and Juliet vs. West Side Story: Parallels and Departures
West Side Story (1957) is a deliberate reimagining of Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet (c. 1595), transposing the Verona feud to 1950s New York City. The structural parallels are unmistakable, but the differences reveal shifting cultural concerns.
Similarities
- Two young lovers from warring factions (Montagues/Capulets → Jets/Sharks)
- Love at first sight at a communal gathering (ball → gym dance)
- Secret marriage/vows (Friar Laurence → mock wedding)
- Tybalt/Bernardo kills Mercutio/Riff; Romeo/Tony kills Tybalt/Bernardo in revenge
- Banishment/separation leads to tragic miscommunication
- Lovers die (suicide / shooting); survivors confront the cost of hatred
Differences
- Setting: Renaissance Verona vs. mid-century Manhattan
- Conflict Basis: Ancient family grudge vs. ethnic/racial tension (white vs. Puerto Rican)
- Age: Teenagers (13–16) vs. young adults (early 20s)
- Maria Lives: Juliet dies; Maria survives to bear witness
- Social Context: Fate and divine will vs. systemic prejudice and urban decay
- Art Form: Verse drama vs. musical theatre (song, dance, orchestral score)
West Side Story doesn't merely adapt—it translates Shakespeare's timeless core into a distinctly American tragedy about immigration, identity, and the failure of the melting pot.