Arts >> Theater >> Drama

Upham's Actions in Saving Private Ryan Knife Scene

Contrary to the question's premise, Upham does help Mellish during the knife fight. After Mellish is stabbed, Upham tackles and disarms the German soldier, saving Mellish's life.

The scene is often misremembered as Upham freezing—but he acts, albeit too late to prevent the stabbing. His intervention stops the German from finishing Mellish off, though Mellish ultimately dies from the wound. Upham's paralysis earlier in the scene (failing to intervene sooner) is the source of his guilt, not total inaction.

Drama

Related Categories