Arts >> Theater >> Drama

Plans to Save Romeo and Juliet: Why They All Failed

Five plans attempt to resolve the lovers' crisis. Only the last—Prince Escalus's posthumous monument—succeeds, and it's too late.

  1. Friar Laurence's Plan: Juliet takes a potion feigning death for 42 hours; Romeo retrieves her from the tomb; they flee to Mantua. Fails: The letter explaining the plan never reaches Romeo.
  2. Romeo's Plan: Unaware of the potion, he buys poison, returns to Verona, and dies beside Juliet's "corpse." Fails: Based on false information.
  3. Balthasar's Plan: Romeo's servant delivers a letter to Lord Montague explaining the tragedy. Posthumous: Only matters after the deaths.
  4. Friar John's Plan: Sent to inform Romeo of the potion scheme. Fails: Quarantined in a plague house; never reaches Mantua.
  5. Prince Escalus's Plan: After the double suicide, he imposes harsh penalties for further violence and proposes a golden statue to honor the lovers. Succeeds: The feud ends, but the lovers are dead.

The tragedy's engine is miscommunication: a letter delayed, a message unread, a plan assumed. Shakespeare makes the postal system an agent of fate.