Derek Morgan: Criminal Minds' Most Popular Character (TVLine Poll 2015)
According to a 2015 TVLine poll, Derek Morgan, portrayed by Shemar Moore, is the most beloved character on Criminal Minds. His eleven-season run cemented his status as the heart of the BAU team.
Why Fans Connect with Morgan
- Charismatic "big brother" dynamic – Protective, loyal, and emotionally available to his colleagues.
- Compelling backstory – Childhood trauma and a Chicago police background add depth and vulnerability.
- Action-oriented role – As the team’s physical specialist, he delivers intense, visceral moments.
- Romantic arc with Savannah Hayes – A grounded, evolving relationship rare for procedural dramas.
- Moore’s magnetic performance – Charisma, intensity, and nuance across 250+ episodes.
Other Fan Favorites
Spencer Reid (Matthew Gray Gubler), Penelope Garcia (Kirsten Vangsness), and Aaron Hotchner (Thomas Gibson) also rank highly, but Morgan’s blend of toughness and tenderness resonated most broadly.