Does Mary Shelley Create Gothic Atmosphere in Frankenstein Primarily Through Setting? No.
No. While setting contributes, the Gothic atmosphere in Frankenstein stems primarily from psychological horror, thematic transgression, and the supernatural rather than gloomy scenery alone.
Why Setting Is Secondary
- Internal > External: The true horror is Victor's obsession, guilt, and the Creature's existential torment—internal states projected onto landscapes.
- Setting as Mirror: The Arctic wastes reflect Victor's isolation; the Orkney cliffs mirror his moral precipice. The landscape expresses the psyche, not vice versa.
- The Uncanny Core: The animation of dead tissue (science as necromancy) and the Creature's eloquent suffering violate natural order—this is the Gothic engine.
Where Setting Does Work Gothicly
- Ingolstadt Lab: "Solitary chamber... filthy workshop" – secrecy, transgression.
- Glaciers/Arctic: Sublime terror, physical manifestation of despair.
- Geneva Storm: Lightning as Promethean fire/omen during William's murder.
Verdict: Shelley uses setting expressively, not decoratively. The Gothic lives in the mind and the monster, not the manor.