Zoey is voted off in Episode 11: "Zeek and Yeek" of Total Drama: Revenge of the Island (Season 4). The elimination challenge involves carrying a giant metal egg—Zoey's team loses, and she receives the final marshmallow (elimination).
Her arc: underestimated "nice girl" → strategic competitor → fan favorite → eliminated just before the merge. Many fans felt she was robbed; her return in All-Stars (Season 5) vindicated her popularity.