Arguments for Friar Lawrence's actions:
1. Good Intentions: Friar Lawrence believed he was helping two young people who were truly in love. He saw their marriage as a way for them to be together and potentially resolve the conflict between their families.
2. Secrecy: By marrying them in secret, he aimed to avoid the immediate hostility and tension that would have arisen if the families had discovered the relationship.
3. Hope for Reconciliation: Friar Lawrence hoped that by uniting Romeo and Juliet, he would eventually bring their families together and end the feud.
Arguments against Friar Lawrence's actions:
1. Unintended Consequences: Friar Lawrence failed to anticipate the tragic consequences of his actions. The secret marriage set in motion a chain of events that led to the deaths of Romeo, Juliet, and several others.
2. Lack of Proper Guidance: Friar Lawrence did not provide Romeo and Juliet with the proper guidance or counseling they needed to navigate their complex situation. He underestimated their impulsiveness and failed to consider the risks involved.
3. Deception: By deceiving the families and keeping the marriage secret, Friar Lawrence contributed to the conflict and distrust between the Montagues and Capulets.
Ultimately, whether Friar Lawrence's actions were right or wrong depends on one's perspective and interpretation of the events. Some argue that his good intentions and desire to help Romeo and Juliet outweighed the unintended consequences, while others believe he should have acted more responsibly and considered the potential risks. It is a matter of moral judgment and interpretation.