Why Holling Thought Romeo and Juliet Were Stupid: Logic Over Passion
Holling (a character in Gary Schmidt’s The Wednesday Wars) judges the star-crossed lovers by a pragmatic, mid-century moral code:
- Emotion Overrides Reason: They marry within hours of meeting; no due diligence, no Plan B.
- Impulsive Violence: Romeo kills Tybalt in a flash of rage, destroying his own future.
- Juliet’s Suicide Is "Especially Foolish": She wakes, sees Romeo dead, and kills herself—after the danger has passed. Holling sees wasted agency.
- No Adult Consultation: They trust only the Friar and Nurse, both of whom fail them.
Holling values calculation, communication, and survival. Shakespeare values intensity, fate, and the beauty of doomed love. They read the same play on different frequencies.