Blaine Anderson (Darren Criss) is a main character on Glee — the original answer incorrectly claimed he didn't exist. However, the show never canonically specifies his coffee order.
Fandom often headcanons:
• Caramel macchiato — sweet, layered, a bit extra (fits Blaine's performative warmth)
• Black coffee — disciplined, serious musician vibe
• Seasonal latte — enthusiastic participant in joy
Glee prioritized musical numbers and plot over mundane character details. Unlike Gilmore Girls (coffee as character shorthand), beverages weren't signature beats.
Bottom line: No canonical answer exists. Your headcanon is as valid as anyone's.