Despite sharing a surname and both being prominent Irish-American Catholics from the Northeast, Dolores Costello and Lou Costello were not related. Genealogical research confirms no familial link between the silent-film star and the comedy legend.
Known as "The Goddess of the Silent Screen," Dolores Costello was a major star of the 1920s. She married John Barrymore in 1928, becoming part of the famed Barrymore acting dynasty. Their daughter, Diana Barrymore, also pursued acting. Dolores' own parents were Maurice Costello and Mae Costello, both actors.
Born Louis Francis Cristillo in Paterson, New Jersey, Lou Costello adopted his stage name early in his career. He formed the iconic duo Abbott & Costello with Bud Abbott, becoming one of the most beloved comedy teams in history. His parents were Sebastian Cristillo and Helen Rege, Italian immigrants.
Both entertainers rose to fame in the early 20th century, shared Irish-American heritage (though Costello was actually Italian-American), and worked in the same industry circles. However, their family trees simply don't intersect. The surname "Costello" is relatively common, and the coincidence of two major stars sharing it has fueled decades of mistaken assumptions.