Arts >> Theater >> Comedy

Does Dr. Manhattan Kill the Comedian in "Watchmen"? No—Here's Who Does

No. In both Alan Moore/Dave Gibbons’ graphic novel and Zack Snyder’s film adaptation, The Comedian (Edward Blake) is murdered by Ozymandias (Adrian Veidt).

What Actually Happens

  1. Blake discovers Veidt’s secret plan to fake an alien attack and unite humanity through fear.
  2. Veidt confronts Blake in his high-rise apartment.
  3. Veidt overpowers him and throws him out the window to his death.
  4. Veidt then engineers a tachyon trap that obscures Dr. Manhattan’s perception of time, framing Manhattan (or at least creating ambiguity) to divert suspicion.

Dr. Manhattan’s Role

Why the Confusion Exists

The film’s nonlinear structure and Manhattan’s omnipresence can blur causality. But the text is clear: Veidt kills Blake to silence him; Manhattan’s complicity is passive (allowing the plan to stand), not active (pulling the trigger).

The Comedian’s death is the catalyst—the pebble that starts the avalanche. Veidt throws it; Manhattan watches it fall.

Comedy

Related Categories