Does Dr. Manhattan Kill the Comedian in "Watchmen"? No—Here's Who Does
No. In both Alan Moore/Dave Gibbons’ graphic novel and Zack Snyder’s film adaptation, The Comedian (Edward Blake) is murdered by Ozymandias (Adrian Veidt).
What Actually Happens
- Blake discovers Veidt’s secret plan to fake an alien attack and unite humanity through fear.
- Veidt confronts Blake in his high-rise apartment.
- Veidt overpowers him and throws him out the window to his death.
- Veidt then engineers a tachyon trap that obscures Dr. Manhattan’s perception of time, framing Manhattan (or at least creating ambiguity) to divert suspicion.
Dr. Manhattan’s Role
- He is a pawn in Veidt’s scheme, not the killer.
- Later, Manhattan vaporizes Rorschach to preserve Veidt’s “peace”—a separate, morally fraught act.
- His detachment and godlike perspective make him vulnerable to manipulation by a peak-human intellect.
Why the Confusion Exists
The film’s nonlinear structure and Manhattan’s omnipresence can blur causality. But the text is clear: Veidt kills Blake to silence him; Manhattan’s complicity is passive (allowing the plan to stand), not active (pulling the trigger).
The Comedian’s death is the catalyst—the pebble that starts the avalanche. Veidt throws it; Manhattan watches it fall.