The original Broadway Annie (1977) was Andrea McArdle, who originated the role at age 12. Sarah Jessica Parker has never played Annie in any Broadway production.
Parker's early stage credits include The Innocents (1976) and Annie touring company (as July, not Annie) — a common source of confusion. She later starred in Ruthless! (1992) and Once Upon a Mattress (1996), but never as the red-headed orphan on the Great White Way.