Arts >> Music >> Songs & Lyrics

Meaning of Phoebe Snow's "Either or Both": Indecision Between Two Lovers

Phoebe Snow's "Either or Both" (from her 1974 debut album) explores the paralyzing indecision of loving two people simultaneously.

Lyrical Landscape

The Chorus

"Either or both, which will it be, either or both?" — The repetition underscores the circular, unresolved nature of the dilemma.

Resolution (or Lack Thereof)

The song does not choose. It ends in the same uncertainty it began with, capturing the messy, non-binary reality of human desire. No neat moral, no decisive turn—just the honest complexity of a heart divided.

Snow's jazz-inflected phrasing and conversational delivery make the confession feel intimate, not performative. A rare song that sits comfortably in the question.

Songs & Lyrics

Related Categories