In the first verse, Derulo reflects on the missed chances and mistakes made in a previous relationship. He wonders if he could have made things right if he had taken a different path, expressing regret for the choices he made. The chorus emphasizes the power of imagination, as the singer asks, "What if I could change the way I feel? What if I could bring back all the time we killed? What if I did the things you wanted me to?" These rhetorical questions convey the singer's internal struggle and his desire to reverse past mistakes.
The pre-chorus reinforces the idea of lost opportunities, with Derulo admitting, "I messed it up, I won't deny." This confession highlights his accountability and willingness to confront his own errors.
In the second verse, the focus shifts to the potential for a new love. Derulo sings, "I'm scared to love, I'm scared to try," expressing a cautious optimism as he contemplates the possibility of finding love again. The chorus then repeats, further intensifying the singer's contemplation and inner conflict.
The bridge of the song builds on this emotional tension, with Derulo imagining a scenario in which he takes a leap of faith and embraces a new relationship. He sings, "What if I could start over? What if I could find someone to call my own? What if I could forget about the past and move on?" These questions emphasize the longing for a fresh start and a chance to rewrite his romantic history.
Throughout the song, "What If" serves as a poignant reflection on the complexities of love, the consequences of past actions, and the hope for new chances and opportunities in the future. It resonates with anyone who has experienced regret and contemplates alternative paths in their romantic journeys.