The lyrics provided appear to be from "The Old Rugged Cross" (Verse 3), though the excerpt doesn't match exactly. The verse goes:
One day they laid Him on the cross, And nailed Him to that old rugged tree. My sins, my sins, brought Him there, But when He looked upon my face, And knew me, how He loved me then, And oh, those eyes of blue!
If this isn't the song you meant, please provide more lyrics for accurate identification.