The song playing during the night drive scene in Hope Floats (1998) with Harry Connick Jr. (Justin) and Sandra Bullock (Birdee) is:
"It Had to Be You" – Isham Jones (music) / Gus Kahn (lyrics), 1924
Version in film: Harry Connick Jr.'s own recording (from his 1990 album We Are in Love or session for the soundtrack). His jazz-piano-vocal style defines the moment—intimate, nostalgic, romantic.
Significance: The standard's lyrics ("It had to be you... nobody else gave me a thrill") mirror Birdee and Justin's unexpected, fated reconnection in their hometown.