Similarities: Both have light, airy timbres, similar tenor ranges, and a relaxed, conversational phrasing style that feels intimate rather than projected.
Differences: Geiger's voice sits slightly higher with a more pronounced vibrato; Mayer often employs a subtle rasp and bluesy inflection. Geiger's tone is typically cleaner, less gritty.
Verdict: Subjective. Some listeners hear a strong resemblance; others distinguish them easily. It's a matter of individual perception—and both artists have evolved vocally across their careers.