Legality of Downloading from LimeWire After Buying CD: Still Illegal
No. Downloading from LimeWire is illegal even if you own a legitimate CD.
Why
- LimeWire is a peer-to-peer network where users share copyrighted files without authorization.
- Purchasing a CD grants personal listening rights only — not distribution rights.
- Downloading from P2P = receiving an unauthorized copy = copyright infringement.
Risks
- Fines, legal action (RIAA lawsuits were real)
- Malware, viruses common in P2P files
- ISP warnings, throttling
Legal Alternatives
- Rip your own CD (format-shifting for personal use — legal in many jurisdictions)
- iTunes, Amazon Music, Bandcamp — purchase downloads
- Streaming with offline mode (Spotify, Apple Music)
Ownership of a physical copy ≠ right to download from unauthorized sources.