Neil Diamond vs. James Taylor: Who Has More Hits? Diamond Wins by the Numbers
By standard chart metrics, Neil Diamond outperforms James Taylor:
- Billboard Top 40 hits: Diamond 38, Taylor 31
- Number-one singles: Diamond 13, Taylor 5
- Diamond-certified singles (10M+ units): Diamond has one solo ("Sweet Caroline"); Taylor has one as a duo with Carole King ("You've Got a Friend"/"Up on the Roof" medley)
Both are Songwriters Hall of Famers, Rock Hall inductees, and American popular song titans. Diamond's commercial peak was higher; Taylor's artistry is often rated more critically. Different measures, different victories.