Arts >> Music >> Other Music

Cwm Rhondda vs. German National Anthem: Different Tunes

No, they are different melodies.

AspectCwm RhonddaDeutschlandlied (German Anthem)
ComposerJohn Hughes (1907)Joseph Haydn (1797)
Original ContextWelsh hymn tune ("Guide Me, O Thou Great Jehovah")Austrian imperial anthem ("Gott erhalte Franz den Kaiser")
Meter8.7.8.7.4.7 (CMD)8.7.8.7.4.7 (CMD)
MelodyDistinct: ascending 4th, stepwise descentDistinct: triadic outline, elegant arch
Stanzas4 (hymn)3 (anthem uses 3rd only since 1952)

Confusion source: Same meter (Common Meter Double) allows text interchangeability. Some German hymnals set "Guide Me, O Thou Great Jehovah" to Haydn's tune; some Welsh sing "Deutschlandlied" text to Cwm Rhondda. But melodies differ.

Other Music

Related Categories