Which Came First: Piano Accordion or Button Accordion? The 1822 vs. 1829 Answer
Piano accordion (1822) predates the button accordion (1829).
The Timeline
- 1822: Friedrich Buschmann (Berlin) builds the Handäoline — piano keyboard on right, bellows, single-action (push-only). First piano-style free-reed portable.
- 1829: Cyrill Demian (Vienna) patents the accordion — button keyboard on right, chordal left hand (major/minor chords on single buttons), bisonoric (push/pull different notes). Coined the name "accordion."
Why It Matters
Buschmann's Handäoline was a melody-only device. Demian's genius was the left-hand chord system — making the accordion a self-contained harmony machine. That's what "accordion" means: accompanying oneself.
Subsequent Evolution
- 1830s–40s: Viennese/French makers add chromatic buttons, improve reeds.
- 1850s: Busson (Paris) creates piano-accordion with stradella bass — merging Buschmann's right hand with Demian's left.
- 1890s: Paolo Soprani (Castelfidardo, Italy) industrializes production — Italy becomes accordion capital.
- 1900s: Chromatic button systems (C-system, B-system) standardized; bayan developed in Russia.
The Irony
The "piano accordion" (Buschmann's right hand + Demian's left hand) became the global standard for classical/jazz/pop — while the "button accordion" (Demian's original right hand + his left hand) remained the folk/traditional choice. Two inventors, two right hands, one shared left hand — and a family tree that's still branching.